Chapter Four
The Battle of White Plains
For almost a month in September, Washington and his men sheltered in Harlem Heights, carefully watching Howe’s every move, waiting for an attack. He made fortifications in preparation for the attack. Finally Howe, on the 12th of October, moved his men into positions that he could attack from. A large portion of his army sailed to Throgg’s Neck, a low peninsula in the main of Westchester County. He left a large enough force with Lord Percy to hold New York City and guard the lines at Harlem. Washington sent Heath to stop Howe’s men from landing, and to occupy lower Westchester. After encountering many difficulties from the rebels, Howe finally took post on the height of New Rochelle, across the road leading to White Plains, where General Knyphausen joined him with a freshly arrived corps of Germans. Meanwhile, General Washington sent McDougall, with his brigade, four miles beyond Kingsbridge, Washington also sent a small force to White Plains. He wanted to get all his men out of Manhattan Island, but a letter from Congress came, ordering him to “Hold Manhattan Island to the last extremity”. At a council of war on October 16th, he proved that the British had plans to surround his army. It was then decided that he would move all of them into Westchester except for the men who would provide a garrison for Fort Washington. The garrison was commanded by Colonel Mcgaw of Pennsylvania. The men under his command were mainly from that state. The army was split into three divisions, commanded by General Lee (the father of Robert E. Lee, who commanded the Army of Northern Virginia in the Civil War.), General Heath, General Sullivan, and General Lincoln. General Greene commanded a small force that made up the garrison of Fort Lee. After daily skirmishing, the two armies, each made up of approximately thirteen thousand men, met in battle at the village of White Plains, on the 28th of October. The rebels were encamped behind quickly put up trenches slightly north of the village. Approximately 1600 men, under Colonel Haslett, had taken post on Chatterton's Hill, which is a high hill on the west side of the present-day Bronx. McDougall was sent there with reinforcements on the morning of the twenty-eighth, with two pieces of artillery, under Colonel Alexander Hamilton. Howe’s army approached in two divisions under General De Heister and General Erskine. Howe was with Erskine. He had approached the shore with caution, and he proceeded to do the same now. He saw the rebels behind their apparently formidable breastworks, and he hesitated. He called a council of war with his generals. He then inclined his army to the left, and on the slopes near a present-day railway station, placed almost twenty field cannons. Under the cover of these, his men constructed a makeshift field bridge across the Bronx, over which British and German forces passed, and attempted to ascend the steep, heavily wooded Chatterton’s Hill, to try to force the Americans off it. Hamilton’s cannons, strategically put there, bothered them exceedingly. They recoiled, when they were joined by reinforcements under Leslie, they drove the rebels out of the hill. McDougall led his troops back to Washington’s camp, leaving the British in charge of Chatterton’s Hill. Howe did not dare to attack Washington’s breastworks (weakly made of corn stalks covered lightly with earth), but waited for reinforcements. They came just as a large storm set in. When the rain stopped in the evening of October 31st, Washington perceiving Howe’s advantage, withdrew under the cover of darkness behind entrenchments on the hills of North Castle toward the Crown River. Howe did not follow Washington, but, falling back, encamped on the heights of Fordham.Washington called a council of war, where it was decided to retreat to New Jersey with a large portion of the army, leaving all the New England troops on the east side of the Hudson to defend against the passes into the Highlands. These troops were placed under the command of General Heath. Five thousand soldiers crossed the Hudson, all at different places. Washington, accompanied by Heath, Stirling, Mifflin, and Generals George and James Clinton, rode to Peekskill, where they went in a barge on an inspection tour of the fortified points in the Highlands. It was then decided to fortify West Point, on the opposite of Fort Constitution. Returning to King’s Ferry, the chief hastened south, where he gathered his army near Hackensack in the rear of Fort Lee, and made his headquarters there on the 14th of December. On the day of the battle at White Plains, Knyphausen, with six German battalions, crossed the bridge at Harlem River Dyckman’s bridge, and encamped on the plain between Fort Washington and Kingsbridge. The rebels nearby stood firmly until the fort was in the hands of the Germans. Washington had left it and Fort Lee under the command of Greene when he heard of the danger it was in, he advised that officer to withdraw the stores and garrison, but left the matter for Greene to decide. When, on the fifteenth, he reached Fort Lee, he was disappointed to find that his wishes were not gratified. Greene wanted to hold the fort as protection for the river; Congress had ordered the fort to be held to the last extremity, and Magaw had said that it could hold the British forces off the whole winter. Yet still Washington was not satisfied with it’s safety, but he yielded and returned to Hackensack. There, at sunset, he received a copy of the reply that Magaw had made to a demand from Howe to surrender. To this demand Magaw protested the savage menace and said that he would defend the fort to the last extremity. Washington immediately rode to Fort Lee. Greene had crossed over to the island. Washington rode a boat in the same direction and met Greene at night returning with Putnam. They told Washington that the garrison was in fine spirits, and confident that they could defend themselves successfully. It was too late to withdraw them, and so Washington returned to Fort Lee, completely unsatisfied. Howe had planted heavy guns on the banks of the Hudson River just above the present-day High Bridge, and from there, on the morning of the nineteenth, fired at the rebels on the outskirts of Fort Washington, to cover the landing of the British attackers, who came up the Hudson during the night on a squadron of ships. Then they had been concealed in Spuyten Duyvil Creek. The rebel outworks were defended on the north-east by Colonel Rawlings, with Maryland militia and riflemen. The lines toward New York were defended by Pennsylvanians under Colonel Lambert Cadwallader. Magaw, of course commanded the fort. Rawlings and Baxter occupied redoubts on rugged and heavily wooded hills. The British attack was made by five columns. Knyphausen, with Hessians and Waldeckers, moved from the plain along the rough hills nearest the Hudson River on the north. At the same time, Lord Percy led a division of English and Hessian troops to attack the lines on the south. General Matthews, supported by Lord Cornwallis, crossed the stream near Kingsbridge, with guards, light infantry, and grenadiers, under cover of the artillery near High Bridge, while Colonel Sterling, with the 42nd regiment of grenadiers, crossed at a point just above the High Bridge. Knyphausen divided his forces. One division, commanded by Colonel Rall, who was killed at Trenton a few weeks later, drove the Americans out of Cock Hill Fort, a small redoubt near Spuyten Duyvil Creek, while Knyphausen, with the remainder, penetrated the woods near Tubby Hook, and, after clambering over rock and fallen trees, attacked Rawlings in a redoubt later called Fort Tryon. Meanwhile, Percy had driven in the rebel pickets at Harlem Cove, and attacked Cadwallader at the advanced line of entrenchments. A fight ensued, and Percy yielded and took shelter behind some woods. While Rawlings and Cadwallader kept the enemy at bay, Matthews and Sterlings were making important movements. Matthews pushed up the wooded heights from his landing place on the Harlem River, drove Baxter from his redoubt, and managed to get to the the hills over the field surrounding Fort Washington. Sterling, with his Highlanders, made a feigned landing, then dropped to a point in the rebel lines, and rushing up a sinuous pathway, captured a redoubt on the summit with two-hundred men. Perceiving this, Cadwallader, who was likely to be placed in the crossfire, retreated along the road nearest to the Hudson. He battled with Percy along the way, who closely pursued him. When he was on One-Hundred and Fifty-First Street, he was attacked on the flank by Sterling, who had gone across the island to intercept him. He made it to the fort with a few killed and around thirty made prisoners. Meanwhile, on the north, the Germans and British, who outnumbered the rebels almost four to one, pressed the rebels back to the fort. Rall sent a message to Magaw to surrender, which was followed by another demand of the same sort from Howe. At noon Magaw surrendered his twenty-five hundred man militia, leaving Fort Washington in the hands of the British. The Americans never got the fort back for the duration of the war.